Reviewer Guidelines

Peer review is essential to maintaining the quality, validity, and relevance of scholarly research. The aim of the peer review process is to provide authors with constructive, objective, and timely feedback in order to improve the quality of their work and ensure high academic standards.

Responsibilities of Reviewers

Reviewers are expected to:

  • Provide objective, constructive, and clear evaluations of submitted manuscripts.
  • Complete reviews within the agreed timeframe (normally within two weeks).
  • Maintain the confidentiality of the manuscript and the review process.
  • Declare any potential conflicts of interest and decline the review if necessary.

Before Accepting a Review

Before agreeing to review a manuscript, reviewers should ensure that:

  • The manuscript falls within their area of expertise.
  • They have sufficient time to complete the review.
  • There is no conflict of interest, including personal, professional, or institutional relationships with the authors.

If a reviewer is unable to accept the invitation, they are encouraged to inform the editorial office promptly and may suggest alternative qualified reviewers.

Peer Review Process

All submitted manuscripts undergo an initial editorial screening to determine whether the submission fits the journal’s scope and basic publication requirements.

Manuscripts that pass the initial screening are subject to a double-blind peer review process in which the identities of both authors and reviewers are concealed.

Each manuscript is reviewed by at least two independent reviewers with relevant expertise in the subject area.

Conducting the Review

Reviewers should evaluate manuscripts based on the following criteria:

  • Originality and contribution to the field.
  • Relevance to the journal’s scope.
  • Clarity and organisation of the manuscript.
  • Soundness of methodology and analysis.
  • Appropriateness and completeness of references.

Reviewers should provide clear comments and suggestions to help authors improve the quality of their manuscripts. Feedback should be constructive, respectful, and specific.

Review Report and Recommendation

After evaluating the manuscript, reviewers are asked to make one of the following recommendations:

  • Accept: The manuscript is suitable for publication without changes.
  • Minor Revision: The manuscript requires minor improvements.
  • Major Revision: The manuscript requires substantial revisions.
  • Reject: The manuscript is not suitable for publication.

Reviewers should support their recommendations with detailed comments for both the editor and the authors.

Ethical Considerations

Reviewers must:

  • Treat all manuscripts as confidential documents.
  • Not use any unpublished material for personal research or advantage.
  • Report any suspected plagiarism, data fabrication, or ethical misconduct.

The journal follows the guidelines and principles of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

Inability to Review

If a reviewer is unable to complete the review within the agreed timeframe, they should inform the editorial office as soon as possible in order to avoid delays in the review process.

For further inquiries, please contact the journal at:

journal@sulicihan.edu.krd